The Banana Bread Switch Up
Posted: March 26, 2012 Filed under: Baking, Quick Breads, Snacks | Tags: Banana Bread, Butterscotch, Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Whole wheat 23 Comments »You are in desperate need of a coffee. You head to the cupboard to grab some filters—but they are not there. You can feel the panic rising as you look in another cupboard, then another. Finally, success…there they are right next to the Cheese Whiz. That’s funny, you didn’t put them there. You breathe a sigh of relief as the coffee brews. Now, just grab a mug and…what the hell, where are the mugs?
I’m sure that this is the scenario (or one very similar) that played out many years ago for my mom. I had just started my first full-time professional job (the one where I met Eva of Kitchen Inspirations) and I had moved in with mom so that I could get my financial feet on the ground. First thing I did was completely rearrange her kitchen.
Need I point out that she wasn’t impressed? Mom was particularly upset when she discovered that several of the items she needed hadn’t just been “relocated”—they’d been thrown in the garbage. I’d like to blame it on my youth—the verve of my adventurous twenties—but I can’t.
I’m just that way. I like to switch things up. You know, make them my own. I know that I’m destined to get what’s coming to me one day soon, as I have two very spirited and strong-willed ponytails.
But until then, I continue to switch things up—particularly with my mom’s recipes. This time, it’s her much-loved banana bread recipe. (It has quite a following with the after-church social crowd at St. Andrew’s Presbyterian Church.) Although, this time I don’t think she will be mad at me—I didn’t throw anything out.
Mom’s Original Banana Bread
- 1-½ cups all purpose flour
- 1 tsp salt
- 1 tsp baking soda
- 3 ripe bananas, mashed
- 1 cup sugar
- 1 egg
- ¼ unsalted butter, melted
- 1 tsp vanilla
Directions
- Mix dry ingredients (flour, salt and baking soda) in small bowl and set aside.
- Mix wet ingredients (bananas, sugar, egg, butter and vanilla) in large bowl. Add dry ingredients and mix well.
- Pour batter into greased loaf pan.
- Bake at 350° for 45 – 50 minutes, or until an inserted toothpick comes out clean.
#1 Switch Up: Whole Wheat Butterscotch Banana Bread
- Replace 1-½ cups all purpose flour with ¾ cup of all purpose flour and ¾ whole wheat flour.
- Add ½ cup butterscotch chips after completing step 2 in directions for Mom’s Original Banana Bread and mix well.
- Follow steps 3 and 4 of same directions.
#2 Switch Up: Marbled Chocolate and Peanut Butter Banana Bread
- Prepare Mom’s Original Banana Bread batter.
- Divide batter in half, placing second half in a new bowl.
- Add 2 tbsps of peanut butter to first half of batter and mix well.
- Add 2-½ tbsps cocoa powder to second half of batter and mix well
- Pour chocolate batter in half of greased loaf pan.
- Then, pour peanut butter batter in other half of greased pan.
- Using a knife or skewer, pull and swirl chocolate batter through peanut butter batter until you are happy with the marbled effect.
- Bake at 350° for 45 – 50 minutes, or until an inserted toothpick comes out clean.



I see March is the banana month for both of us
You have made me think once more I should bake more with wholewheat flour…
The breads sound and look great. I am not surprised: even modified, mums’ recipes always work
The wholewheat flour seems to swap out pretty well in these types of recipes. It makes me feel like I’m being a little healthier…..don’t think it means you can have several slices though!
Hi Barb! I remember those days with your Mom very well. And I loved her cozy home and kitchen. Will try the pb marble recipe! Great ideas. I don’t use much artificial flavouring when I bake, but usually add a drop of ‘banana flavour’ to my banana bread recipe in case the bananas aren’t flavourful enough.
Can’t wait to visit in person in June!
XO
Thanks for your comment Carol. Those days seem so long ago now. Never tried “banana flavour” before ….I’ll have to look for it. Looking forward to our visit!
I just made banana bread on the weekend with a new recipe.. mine’s the conservative type, like your mom’s:) I love your change ups!!
Do you have a million ripe bananas in your freezer too Barb? I’m constantly trying to use them up ….and the bread makes a great snack for the girls’ lunch bags.
They never make it to the freezer, lol. The kids and I regularly make protein shakes.. until they get so black they turn their noses up and I make banana muffins:) Happy Easter!!
You know we haven’t had banana bread in a while…might be time for another loaf.
I can imagine that you might be a bit tired of it after your round up earlier this year!
I just made banana bread yesterday, but love the idea of these switch-ups, and especially the butterscotch one because I know it would be so good with the bananas. What a great idea, Barb!
Butterscotch and banana really goes well together Betsy. It is definitely worth a try next time you make banana bread!
I’m actually surprised your Mom didn’t throw you out! The banana bread looks great…all the way from Mexico?
Luckily she kept me around! I tried my hand at scheduling….looks like it worked!
Switch up #2 Marbled Chocolate and Peanut Butter Banana Bread is my kind of banana bread. Anything with chocolate and banana.
It is a great combination, isn’t it Norma! My husband is right there with you!
These switch ups are so creative and delicious versions of this classis bread – fabulous blog
Happy Easter!
Choc Chip Uru
Thanks so much for your comment — and for dropping by. I’m heading over to your blog now.
[...] http://profiterolesandponytails.wordpress.com/2012/03/26/the-banana-bread-switch-up/ [...]
[...] oldest daughter started requesting a new version of banana bread . . . she was getting sick of my Butterscotch Chip Wholewheat Banana Bread. That lead to thinking that I needed to try the coconut oil that I’ve been reading about [...]
Loving the butterscotch!! Yummy
I like the switch up! Both recipes look AWESOME! Must try